Product Comparison: HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 vs. HPE Q1J10A D3710 vs. HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040

Introduction

In today’s data-driven world, the demand for efficient, reliable, and scalable data storage solutions is at an all-time high. As businesses grow, so does the volume of data they generate, manage, and analyze. For data storage managers and IT professionals, choosing the right storage solution can significantly impact operational efficiency and business performance.

This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison of three prominent HPE storage solutions: the HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 SAN Dual Controller LFF Storage, the HPE Q1J10A D3710 25-Bay 2.5in SFF SAS/SATA Disk Enclosure for G10, and the HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 Energy Star SAN Dual Controller SFF Storage. By understanding their key features, user experience, cost versus value, and ideal customer profiles, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your organization’s unique needs.

Understanding the Key Features

HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 SAN Dual Controller LFF Storage

Overview:

• Device Type: Hard Drive Array
• Form Factor: 2U Rack-Mountable
• Capacity: Up to 960 TB LFF maximum raw capacity
• Drive Description: Supports 12 LFF SAS/MDL SAS/SSD
• Host Interface: 16 Gb/8 Gb Fibre Channel or 1GbE/10GbE iSCSI
• Storage Controller: Two HPE MSA 2050 SAN controllers
• RAID Levels: RAID 1, RAID 5, RAID 6, RAID 10
• Power Consumption: 390 Watts
• Key Features: Flash-ready, 200,000 IOPS, automated tiering, data-in-place upgrades, encrypted SSDs and HDDs, remote replication, and virtualized snapshot technology.

HPE Q1J10A D3710 25-Bay 2.5in SFF SAS/SATA Disk Enclosure for G10

Overview:

• Device Type: Storage Enclosure
• Form Factor: 2U Rack-Mountable
• Capacity: Up to 45 TB with 1.8 TB SAS drives, scalable to 200 SFF drives
• Drive Description: Supports 25 SFF SAS/SATA/SSD
• Host Interface: 12Gbps SAS
• Storage Controller: Compatible with Smart Array P421, P431, P441, P822, P841, and others
• Power Consumption: 460 Watts
• Key Features: Redundant fans, firmware upgradable, high storage density, and modular design for easy expansion.

HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 Energy Star SAN Dual Controller SFF Storage

Overview:

• Device Type: Hard Drive Array
• Form Factor: 2U Rack-Mountable
• Capacity: Up to 400 TB raw storage capacity
• Drive Description: Supports 24 SFF SAS/SSD
• Host Interface: 8Gb/16Gb Fibre Channel or 1GbE/10GbE iSCSI
• Storage Controller: Two HPE MSA 2040 SAN controllers
• RAID Levels: RAID 0, RAID 1, RAID 3, RAID 5, RAID 6, RAID 10, RAID 50
• Power Consumption: Not specified
• Key Features: Dual protocol support (FC and iSCSI), high performance, scalability, redundancy, and user-friendly management interface.

Analyzing the User Experience

HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 SAN Dual Controller LFF Storage

This model stands out for its user-friendly management interface and robust performance metrics. It supports high IOPS, making it ideal for applications requiring rapid data access. Features like automated tiering and virtualized snapshot technology enhance usability and data management efficiency.

HPE Q1J10A D3710 25-Bay 2.5in SFF SAS/SATA Disk Enclosure for G10

Users appreciate the modular design of this storage enclosure, which allows for easy expansion as storage needs grow. The inclusion of redundant fans and firmware upgradeability ensures reliable operation and long-term use. It seamlessly integrates with ProLiant servers, enhancing its appeal to existing HPE customers.

HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 Energy Star SAN Dual Controller SFF Storage

This model is praised for its dual protocol support, high performance, and user-friendly management interface. It is particularly well-suited for virtualized environments and industries requiring high data security. The robust RAID options offer flexibility in data protection and redundancy.

Cost vs. Value

HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 SAN Dual Controller LFF Storage

Price:$6,899.95

The initial investment for the HPE MSA 2050 may be higher than some alternatives, but its advanced features and high performance justify the cost. The ability to scale up to 960 TB and support for encrypted SSDs/HDDs provide long-term value, making it a cost-effective solution for growing businesses.

HPE Q1J10A D3710 25-Bay 2.5in SFF SAS/SATA Disk Enclosure for G10

Price:$864.95 each

As the most affordable option among the three, the HPE D3710 offers excellent value for enterprises needing scalable and flexible storage solutions. Its high storage density and modular design mean it can grow with your business, minimizing the need for frequent hardware upgrades.

HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 Energy Star SAN Dual Controller SFF Storage

Price:$4,724.95

Priced between the MSA 2050 and the D3710, the MSA 2040 offers a balanced mix of high performance, scalability, and security features. Its dual protocol support and robust RAID options make it a versatile choice for medium to large enterprises, providing substantial long-term value.

Ideal Customer Match

HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 SAN Dual Controller LFF Storage

Ideal for small to medium-sized businesses (SMBs) and remote offices, the MSA 2050 is perfect for those seeking affordable, high-performance storage with flexibility and advanced data protection features. Organizations with mixed workloads will benefit from its automated tiering and high IOPS.

HPE Q1J10A D3710 25-Bay 2.5in SFF SAS/SATA Disk Enclosure for G10

This model is best suited for enterprises with high storage demands and data centers requiring scalable, high-density storage solutions. It is also ideal for organizations with ProLiant servers looking to expand storage capacity seamlessly.

HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 Energy Star SAN Dual Controller SFF Storage

Medium to large enterprises and virtualized environments will find the MSA 2040 to be the optimal choice. It is particularly beneficial for industries with high data security needs, such as healthcare and finance, thanks to its redundancy and data protection features.

Conclusion

Choosing the right storage solution requires a careful analysis of your organization's specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. Each of the HPE models discussed offers unique advantages tailored to different business scenarios:

• HPE Q1J00A MSA 2050 is ideal for SMBs and remote offices needing affordable, high-performance storage with scalability and advanced data protection features.
• HPE Q1J10A D3710 suits enterprises and data centers requiring high-density, scalable storage with redundancy and compatibility with ProLiant servers.
• HPE 717870-001 MSA 2040 is best for medium to large enterprises and virtualized environments needing high-performance, scalable, and secure storage solutions.

For more information on these storage solutions and how they can benefit your organization, contact our experts at Storage Parts Direct. Make an informed decision and invest in the future of your business today.